Linux: Still Sucking

by Paul Sherman on July 1, 2006 · 3 comments

in Everything Else

I really, really want to like Linux. But it’s just not likable. Because it’s just not usable! Case in point: I downloaded and installed the latest version of the Xandros Desktop distribution. I actually got further than I did with the Ubuntu cluster-f of April, in that Xandros recognized my Ethernet card, grabbed a DHCP-assigned NAT address from my router, and got onto the Internet without me having to futz around.

But here’s the thing: anytime I try to do ANYTHING to a Linux installation that requires even a small bit of customization, everything goes down the toilet.

Like I said, Xandros came up and I got on the Internet, but the screen resolution was 1024x768x16 bit. I have a Dell 20″ widescreen LCD with a native resolution of 1680×1050. Running at any other resolutions looks crappy. So like a good geek, I tried to change the color depth and resolution in the Xandros control panel.

I pulled the slider till it read “1680×1050″. The system prompted me to logout/login. I did. And when it came back up, it was STILL 1024×768. And get this: the slider actually read “1680×1050.” Criminy…

So, I figured “driver problem.” I browsed over to the nVidia site, found the Linux drivers, downloaded them, and attempted to follow the install directions. Only here’s the other thing: the instructions quite unhelpfully omit the fact that YOU’RE SUPPOSED TO STOP THE X SERVER. I only found that out when I read an “alternate” set of instructions that were buried deep within the nVidia support site.

Here’s the coup de grace: I don’t know how to shut down the X server while still logged in as root, find the install package, run it, and get back to the graphical desktop.

Why oh why don’t Linux developers understand that driver and application installs should just work? I shouldn’t have to jump through hoops. I just want my monitor to work at it’s native resolution. Is that too much to ask?

  • http://celeduc.blogspot.com Chuck LeDuc

    The hardware manufacturers are the ones that have to get behind Linux. Once they see value in contributing to driver libraries and distributions it’ll get very good, very fast. Right now Linux users are fixing the problems themselves — thousands of times over. It’s too hard to submit a fix, open source projects are bureaucratic (unlike a wiki). We’ve got to get the hardware makers to support linux (which means voting with the wallet) and open up the projects to more rapid contribution.

  • http://www.niknet.co.uk Nick

    NO, no, no!!! It is NOT the hardware makers but the blasted developers who insist on making Linux as difficult and over complicated as alienly possible.

    If drivers installed by err, double clicking on them, then people would use them. No one uses Linux because it’s obscure, difficult and designed by complete nerds for nerds. I too really, really want to like it, like a classic car, but frankly no one working on it has the slightest clue how people use a computer.

    A lot has been done. Much more needs to be. I mean, does windows ever pop up a statement of “you need to restart zlibf.mod-odd.so”?

    My advice – get your Mum to use it. Even better, your Grandma. Get them to install programs, see how confusing the UI is, see how awkward things are made, how deliberately technical, and consequently how untrustworthy.

    Stop writing code, and start seeing how people use a computer, not how you want them to use it.

  • lele85

    Just don’t use it. Nobody force you to use it. It’s so simple… Anyway the tipical “Grandma” use of PC is just surf internet, read email… not install programs or kernel modules!
    Sorry for the bad english, but i’m Italian!

Previous post:

Next post: